Download Constitutional Context: Women and Rights Discourse in by Kathleen S. Sullivan PDF

By Kathleen S. Sullivan

While the us was once based on summary ideas of convinced "unalienable rights," its criminal traditions are dependent in British universal legislations, a truth lengthy decried through innovative reformers. universal legislations, the criticism is going, ignores summary rights rules in desire of culture, successfully denying equality to giant segments of the inhabitants.

The nineteenth-century women’s rights flow embraced this argument, claiming that universal legislations principles of estate and married women’s prestige have been at odds with the nation's dedication to equality. traditional knowledge means that this tactic helped pave the way in which for vote casting rights and higher jobs. In Constitutional Context, Kathleen S. Sullivan offers a clean perspective.

In revisiting the era’s congressional debates, kingdom laws, judicial critiques, information bills, and paintings of political activists, Sullivan unearths that the argument for common, summary rights was once now not the one, or top, course on hand for social switch. instead of erecting a brand new paradigm of absolute rights, she argues, women’s rights activists unwittingly undermined universal law’s skill to redress grievances, contributing seriously to the social, cultural, and political stagnation that characterizes where of girls and the flow today.

A hard and considerate research of what's mostly considered an period of growth, Constitutional Context offers the basis for a extra finished figuring out and interpretation of constitutional law.

Show description

Read Online or Download Constitutional Context: Women and Rights Discourse in Nineteenth-Century America (The Johns Hopkins Series in Constitutional Thought) PDF

Best civil rights books

Profiles, Probabilities, and Stereotypes

This ebook employs a cautious, rigorous, but energetic method of the well timed query of no matter if we will be able to justly generalize approximately contributors of a bunch at the foundation of statistical developments of that workforce. for example, should still an army academy exclude girls simply because, on common, girls are extra delicate to hazing than males?

The Women of CourtWatch: Reforming a Corrupt Family Court System

'The ladies of CourtWatch did what they have been advised could not be performed. They drove a gaggle of strong and entrenched kinfolk court docket judges off the bench - an individual referred to as them 'the babes who slew the Goliath. ' It used to be rather a victory' - Carole Bell Ford, from the advent. Houston was once a bad position to divorce or search baby custody within the Eighties and early Nineties.

Feminist and queer legal theory : intimate encounters, uncomfortable conversations

Feminist and Queer felony conception: Intimate Encounters, Uncomfortable Conversations is a groundbreaking assortment that brings jointly best students in modern felony thought. the quantity explores, from time to time contentiously, convergences and departures between a number of feminist and queer political initiatives.

God, Schools, and Government Funding: First Amendment Conundrums

Lately, a conservative majority of the U. S. very best court docket, over full of life dissents, has constructed circumventions to the institution Clause of the 1st modification that permit kingdom legislatures unabashedly to take advantage of public tax funds to help inner most easy and secondary schooling, with nearly all of that investment achieving parochial colleges and different religiously-affiliated schooling services.

Extra info for Constitutional Context: Women and Rights Discourse in Nineteenth-Century America (The Johns Hopkins Series in Constitutional Thought)

Sample text

The common lawyers’ doubts about the comprehensiveness of a code reflected a deeper concern. It was not just that the code could not cover all legal issues; a written code with a litany of laws did not capture what it meant to have law. Law was not merely a collection of words on a piece of paper but a reflection of larger experience, in its inception and in its interpretation. ”107 Common lawyers retained the notion that law grew out of a community and that the law has meaning beyond the words on a piece of paper.

Instead of conceding defeat, common lawyers responded by flipping the charges Sampson and his advocates leveled, thus revealing the premises and consequences of the positivist sentiments that codifiers were inviting into American law. Sampson was an Irish immigrant who had been a participant in the Irish rebellion against the British in 1798. 81 He brought skepticism for Anglo law, first-hand frustrating experience with an overpowering criminal justice system, and familiarity with legal reform in France.

Good,” Bentham responded, “but how am I to come at this general reason . . I cannot go round the world and count suffrages. ”30 Bentham proffered another standard: “Had our Author again instead of reason said utility, he would have said something. He would have referred us for a foundation for our judgment, to something distinct from that judgment itself. ”31 In laying down an incipient theory of utilitarianism, Bentham applied an analytic jurisprudential critique to the common-law method, seeking a scientific calculation to provide certainty in the face of the vagueness and discretion of common-law methods.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.17 of 5 – based on 43 votes